Daniel Foggo
Star musicians and your favourite Times writers at the Albert Hall

GORDON BROWN’S pledge to honour members of the public for heroism during terrorist attacks has been labelled a sham after dozens of civilians who went to the rescue of the 7/7 bombing victims were snubbed for awards.
Pleas to honour ordinary civilians have been rejected as undeserving - even though more than two dozen public sector staff, some of whom were doing desk jobs, have been honoured for their conduct on 7/7.
Martin Bell, the former independent MP who has called for a review of the honours system, said: “It is the usual - senior people are rewarded and the little guys are not.”
Brown made the pledge last July at the launch of a book he wrote on heroism, titled Britain’s Everyday Heroes. He said: “It is right that we look at how our honours system can recognise those in our emergency services and members of the public who showed such bravery and heroism in the face of the recent terrorist attacks.”
However, Tim Coulson, a teacher who went to the aid of the victims of the Edgware Road tube station suicide bombing in July 2005, was snubbed after his wife Judy applied on his behalf this year.
Coulson smashed his way into the stricken carriage from another train adjacent to it in the tunnel and gave first aid to the injured and dying. One man, whose body had been severed at the waist by the blast, died in his arms.
Coulson, 53, who lives in Henley-on-Thames, Oxfordshire, still suffers from post traumatic stress and was forced to retire early from his job after collapsing at work.
Although her husband’s case was backed by testimonies from those he helped and witnesses to his heroism, the Cabinet Office told Judy Coulson in a letter that “honours are awarded to people for meritorious service over a sustained period and not specifically for saving someone’s life”.
But various public sector workers were given a range of awards in the new year’s honours list two years ago in direct recognition of their conduct on 7/7. They included CBEs for the heads of Transport for London and the London Underground, OBEs for senior representatives of the police, ambulance service and Salvation Army, and MBEs for those, such as the supervisor at Russell Square Tube station, who helped injured passengers.
The range of Queen’s honours also includes four gallantry awards, ranging from the Queen’s Commendation for Bravery to the George Cross, which are open to civilians who show courage while trying to save others’ lives. The Cabinet Office web-site, which details the gallantry awards, invites nominations from members of the public.
The George Cross, which can be given to either military personnel or civilians and is equivalent to the Victoria Cross, has been granted 159 times since its creation in 1940. Its most recent recipient is Corporal Mark Wright, who died in Afghanistan in 2006 while leading fellow soldiers through a minefield.
The Queen’s Commendation for Bravery is awarded more frequently, although mostly to police officers. A year ago it was given to Michael Winstanley, a civilian, for helping to rescue two people from a crashed light aircraft.
Critics said the revelation demonstrated why the honours list needed to be urgently reviewed. Bell said: “They promised a reform of the honours system and this was a classic case in which it could have been delivered and it hasn’t.”
Peter Zimonjic, the author of a new book on the 7/7 bombings called Into the Darkness, said he was aware of at least two dozen members of the public who had performed similar acts of bravery to Coulson yet none had been officially recognised.
Zimonjic, who was nearby when the Edgware Road bomb exploded, said: “Gordon Brown has said ‘we want to honour ordinary people’ and yet the reality is that it is just hot air.
“If someone like Tim Coulson is not deserving of official recognition then what kind of signal does that send out?
“I know that when the honours were announced for all the public sector workers for carrying out their jobs well on 7/7, it did annoy those members of the public who came to the rescue themselves. They felt entirely overlooked.”
Julian Spicer, chairman of the Royal Humane Society which is to give Coulson a bravery award in the spring, said the government was “ridiculous” to hand honours to public servants for their actions on 7/7 while snubbing members of the public.
Rachel North, a victim of 7/7, said: “My personal opinion is that people who performed acts of heroism on that day should be publicly thanked for it.”
Coulson, who was not aware of his wife’s application to the Cabinet Office at the time, said he still gets flashbacks from 7/7.
He said: “The first few moments were about fear for my own life, but following that there was the reality that I was not dead while others were in agony. It was like a trigger that I must do something to help.”
With a handful of other men, Coulson battered through a plate glass window dividing his train’s carriage from the one in which Mohammad Sidique Khan had blown himself up, and climbed through into the unknown.
He said: “I saw things I had never seen in my life before, people in pieces and others who were dying.” He began tending to the wounded, including putting a tourniquet on one man’s leg, before finding a man trapped in a crater where the floor of the carriage had been.
Unable to free him, Coulson climbed out of the carriage and attempted to grasp the man from below, at which point he realised that his lower body had been severed.
Lowering the man to the floor, Coulson held him and said a prayer as he died in his arms.
Then he went to the aid of a woman who was slumped against the tunnel wall having been blown out of the train by the blast.
He tended to her wounds and comforted her for more than an hour until help arrived from the emergency services.
In a statement she provided to the Cabinet Office, the woman, whose identity is being withheld by The Sunday Times to protect her privacy, said: “It takes an instinct that the majority of us don’t possess to throw yourself into potential danger rather than the instinct for self-preservation.
“It is hard to put into words the kind of gratitude I feel towards Tim. He is indeed the bravest person I’ve known and I feel deserves the recognition of his bravery.”
The Cabinet Office declined to comment.
Follow our three athletes' progress in their preparations for the London Triathlon, and pick up training tips and more
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles


A treasure trove of baubles, booty and stylish quests


Overseas contacts and local business information

£129,500
Bentley Edinburgh
£79,850
Mercedes-Benz of Northampton
£26,995
Unit 1, Woodfield Business Unit, Kidderminster Road, Ombersley, Worcester.
Great car insurance deals online
90k + Bonus + Options
Confidential
London
£23,716 +
Highways Agency
National
£
£43,405 - £48,228 pa
Notting Hill Housing
London
£30,000 base, £100,000 OTE
Riches Consulting
London/South
with annexe accommodation and 5.25 acres
£1,100,000
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Studios £33K, 1 Beds £60K, 2 beds £79K
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Explore mystical Jordan
From £1030 for 7nts 4*
to USA's Most Cosmopolitan City; San Francisco!
£POA
Book Now for Winter 08/09 and Get 10% off!
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Search globrix.com to buy or rent UK property. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I'm surprised that Amy Winehouse was not created a 'Dame?
Well stranger things are happening under this dither orientated government!
prudence eely bond mcguire, London, England, UK.
It shows terrible judgement! I suppose the government needs to do what it can to prop up Her Majesty's popularity.
Is Kylie going to stick the medal on her bum?
Catherine, Sydney, Australia
Never mind Mr Coulson, the British people will hold you in their highest esteem. We will thank you for your courage and right thinking.
The government and Brown will receive all the contempt it deserves.
Jim Hatch, Acapulco, Mexico
Whilst not seeking to disparage those actually receiving awards in this years List, I and my teenage daughters and wife are all in agreement that the oversight of these brave civilians is an affront to common sense and yet again devalues the honours system. And the Establishment wonder why the people of today hold politicians in such contempt!
Brent Patterson, Halifax, West Yorkshire
I am Australian born, of English parents and it stands to reason, that, of course I love Kylie,
However, she is not British and I was under the illusion, these
awards, are, to honour, British citizens.
Australians, have their own awards, notably, the OAM.
Brown is dithering again. He just can't help it!
prudence eely bond mcguire, London, England, UK.
Isn't there a 'Yes Minister' episode about the award of honours to public servants? Nothing much has happened in the last 25 years, it seems. Still a cosy little club.
MarkS, Leeds,
Does anyone actually believe the Bean any more? His promises should be nominated for the Nobel Prize for fiction. Unfortunately, he loves instant popularity so his reaction is always to promise something good on the spot - however, don't expect him to deliver- he never does. .
Doug, Glasgow,
Did you really expect anything other than a public sector back-slapping club. The public sector bigwig club is just as obnoxious as the 'old boy' network Labour claims to despise. And besides aren't terms like "meritorious service over a sustained period" complete misnomers when used in conjunction with 'management' and 'public sector'?
As for Gordon and his book (has anyone actually read it? I had a look on Amazon and nobody's reviewed it yet!) - the guy just gives me the creeps.
Jonathan, Auckland, New Zealand
wow, thats a shocker Gordon Brown says he will honour real people and then it turns out he lied and only awards the people from the establishment, the only time a politician tells the truth is when they order food.
Why do we accept leaders with such disdain for their people?
jay, cardiff,
Gordon's not interested in heroes, just those people who give cash to the Party.
And why should he keep this promise? It sounded good at the time so it already served its purpose, right?
steve, London, UK
I can think of no better reason for living in a country that does not have a honours system. I feel ashamed to be born in the UK.
Alf Walshaw, Laxanada, Greece
It's a pity that New Labour seems to actually be the Tories of old.
richard dows, louth, lincolnshire
If you're not yet bothered and bewildered enough by the Honours List then just let your imaginations roll and consider what glorious deeds have been done by the following for their pretty senior awards (CBs/CBEs - no names, just titles, to spare their embarrassment)
Chief Executive, Border and Immigration Agency
Deputy Chairwoman, the Better Regulation Commission (the Quangoes' Quango?)
Commissioner, the National Lottery
Director of Child Benefit and Tax Credit Offices, HM Revenue & Customs
- and last but not least, my personal favourite:
Head of Histories, Openness (!!??), and Records Unit, Cabinet Office
Gordon Alexander, Frome, UK
I see there were CBEs for the heads of Transport for London and the London Underground. Excuse me, but weren't these people merely doing their jobs? ...For which they receive handsome salaries and fat pensions? So what exactly are the gongs for?
Par for the course, isn't it?
Brian Clacey, Croydon, UK
What else can you expect from a country that gives knighthoods to chat show hosts?
Real public service means NOTHING.
Michael Rigby, Blackburn, England
It always amazes me how someone can be awarded (for example) services to music when they already get highly paid, are already extremely weathly, get whatever they want whenever they want it and all for doing something that they love and want to do! Why honour them for having a 'perfect' life?
These honours really should be about the people who, through no financial gain, help others and save lifes.
As an aside, i can't quite get my head around why Karen Millen is getting an award. What has she done apart from make overpriced clothes while in the process making herself extremely rich?
Kim, London,
I well remember 7/7, with Labour politicians queuing up to spin about how it was nothing to do with Iraq. They betrayed us all then, and they are still betraying us now with this.
They are desperate to hand over power to the EU (likely future president Blair, helped by Brown's refusal to hold a referendum over the EU constitution in return for being allowed to become PM).
Blair's coal-mining constituency is all but moribund now Labour insists on getting power from nuclear plants and windmills. They use illegal immigration to keep down the wages of their suporters, and I am perfectly prepared to believe that their continued demands for more housing to be built are thnaks to somebody donating money to the party- we all know where that can get you.
John Towers, Croydon, UK
PAH! What a disgrace. When will the humble and modest hero/ine be rewarded for their integrity, dignity, compassion, decency, kindness and courage? The real heroes never ask for anything in return - because they are completely selfless, unlike the greedy and self-aggrandizing 'celeb', already generously rewarded for their so called 'talents'. I don't wish Kylie Minogue any ill - but I can think of a dozen people who deserve to be recognised for the work they do and the lives they save. Perhaps the 'pop princess' needs to be reminded of the now eponymous and rather dull song...'I should be so lucky', for never a truer word has she 'spoken. -- To all the unsung heroines and heroes of Britain I would like to thank you all for your bravery and courageous acts of kindness, compassion and selflessness. Happy new year to you all.
ellajo, London, UK
There were not enough medals to go round.
Obviously deserving cases had to be given priority.
Like the sawmill manager at Sandringham, a farm foreman at Sandringham, a former flower arranger at Hollyroode, a 'page of the backstairs' and a 'Yeoman bed goer'.
Don't believe me? Read through the whole list for yourself.
Clearly in comparison with all these 'heroes' a chap who saved lives doesn't stand a chance.
It is fast becoming more prestigious NOT to have letters after your name.
GJB, Slough, Berkshire
There will , of course, be a huge kneejerk reaction by the government following the comment's from Mr Bell and other's, showing the government in their true colour's.
The rudder has well and truly fallen off this sinking ship, can anyone in Westminster make a decision let alone the correct one ?
Perhaps Whitehall has tried to tuck Mr Brown up with this error of judgement , perhaps to help him on his final journey from government.
Has anyone seen Gordon Brown out and about the U.K since he became Le Grand Fromage ?
Nick Dixon, Sutton Coldfield, West Midlands
Of course the Cabinet Office would refuse to comment. It takes common sense to comment and they have shown yet again their complete lack
Simon, Warwick,
Gordon Brown is a shifty dour politician who depends on the Muslim & anti English vote. He'd rather hand out no awards in cases involving bravery in the face of Islam. Instead of reminding us of the butchery by awarding the brave , he's given awards to pen pushers. I'll bet some of these people were told to downplay the Islamic element if they wanted a gong.
martin bright, Bracknell,
Pathetic! Media faces who are handsomely paid anyway receive honours, as do time serving politicians and civil servants. Risk your life to save others and you get nothing. Having said that, perhaps the government ARE just reflecting the state of the nation. How many millions of people vote for nobodies doing nothing on programmes such as Big Brother and then buy magazines with their photos on the front? The heroes of 7/7 will be valued by 'right thinking' people without honours. Perhaps Parky and Kylie will do the decent thing and turn down their awards in protest.
Clive, Chichester, UK
Brown is a disgrace and will only do or say things he considers populous , his cynicism stinks look at the crap about troop numbers and all the ballyhoo about how brave they are while all the time he was sending them to war with shoddy equipment. He is the best thing to happen to the Labour party as he single handedly made sure they will never get elected again for a very , very long time. Thank god!
D Case, Newquay,
what else do you expect from this country? duplicity has always been the watchword.
Phil Barnes, preston, england
Easy answer why no awards - Labour Party NOT receiving any monetary benefit!!
Iain, Stornoway, Scotland
Perhaps the George Cross is too high an honour for mere heroism without the obvious threat of immediate personal risk, but somewhere in the nations coffers there must be a civilian award to give to Mr Coulson (and others) for such outstanding behaviour.
But then again, the days are long gone when we had an honourable admininstration under the government. It rubs off, you know.
Mike Poulsen, Reading, Berkshire
It would appear that running a large retail store, being a chat show host and commenting on football, rank higher in this governments opinion that risking ones life to help people injured in terrorist attacks when it comes to handing out honours.
David Walker, Burnley, Lancashire
Our honours system has always been a joke. Those who have made a fortune for themselves and those who work for the government as well as celebrities are lavished with awards whist the truely brave and people who have worked tirelessly for the public good without pay are just ignored. I know - I have a number of experiences in that field.
Politicians regularly promise to clean it up (I remember John Major making such a promise) but, of course, just as in "Yes Minister" it is the Civil Servants who decide - and nobody is going to take their perks away from them, are they!
Nigel Rawlings, Tonbridge, Kent
Patronage keeps the Windsors in a job.Remove patronage and the Monarchy will disappear.
Parkinson spent years droning on monotonously,pulling at his ear lobes and rubbing his finger up and down his nose,whilst a whole host of hopefuls came on to flog their latest book,record,film or tv show to a captive audience stuck in on a saturday night with nothing else to watch on the telly.
Knowing now hat TV companies can get up to me I shouldn't be surprised to learn that all the so-called "guests" paid to be on the show,hence its longevity.
Next time a terrorist comes to town get Parkinson to interview him.
alan madox, wirral, ENGLAND
There is very little you can say when people perform these minor miracles to help others in need, other than a truly-deserved 'thank you'. Public recognition of these thanks is a fundamental requirement. We need to glorify the efforts of others in order to show the behavious we feel appropriate in the world.
If we don't, our stinking society will go even further down the drain - "I'm alright Jack, pull the ladder up!"
P Conway, Manchester, England
It is typical to see that cronies and pop singers who don't even write their own music are awared. I suspect this is to gain publicity to help gain a few votes from their fans. Meanwhile people who save lives day in and day out, or show spectacular braverly to help others in the face of adversity are routinely ignored.The honours system is a sham and should be suspended and then relaunched and run by an independant body - politicians have been allowed to abuse it long enough.
Rob Burrows, Birtley, England, Co Durham
The word 'honours' is I think an oxymoron - we have here a corrupt system managed by corrupt people. Time for it to be 'binned'..
M Joyce, Ely, Cambs
Can someone just remind me what Kylie Minogue has done to deserve an OBE ?
Martha, Rickmansworth,
Kylie Minogue? I was disgusted to read the article,people who have made a real contribution have been ignored and an Australian pop singer gets a gong! OK she has had breast cancer, but so have millions of women who coped with far less of a song and dance, (and considerably less money),and continued to run a home and look after kids.The system should be scrapped.
Helen Faulkes, Solihull, England
To honour the heroes, Bottler Brown would have had to make a decision. Which, as we know, he runs a mile from! Typical of the gutless Stalinist!
jm smith, london,
Dear Editor
2007 is the centenary of the Irish writer Louis Macneice, one of whose more memorable quotes is "Sit on your arse for 40 years and hang your hat on a pension". That's the mindset of Cabinet Office people and, funny old thing, I think you'll find that people who have served in the place have quite well represented in the Honours List, despite rarely done anything other than squat on the same portion of anatomy,
Peter Wyton, Gloucester, U.K.
The Cabinet Office and the Labour Government have once again proved themselves to be an utter disgrace.
Mark, Hong Kong,
The whole system stinks.
neil, kl, malaysia
Once again it has been proven that when it comes to honours, New Labour has no honour at all!
Bob Evans, Anaheim, California
I feel that these people should not be labelled as "undeserving" and should be rewarded in Gordon Brown's pledge or in some other way if possible, as I would consider them to be a hero since they were trying to save peoples lives.
Yasser, Toronto , Canada
If this is true then the 'honours' system is absolutely tainted in this instance. It appears to be a civil servant honours system with a somewhat incestuous look about it.
Billy Bud, Perth, Australia
Surely people like Kyle Minogue and Parky are more deserving of an award than ordinary Joe Public who will risk there lives and well being coming to the aid of others.
I for one think Kyle has a lovely bottom and deserves all the awards she can get.
Chris Williamson, Blyth, Notts